Archive for the ‘review’ Category

Book review: Riot at the Calc Exam and Other Mathematically Bent Stories

Friday, January 8th, 2010

You’ve heard the story of Rumpled Stiltsken, right? You know, the one where the topologist’s daughter is locked in the grad student lounge and forced to turn coffee into theorems by morning? …what’s that, you say you haven’t heard that one? Funny, I thought everyone knew that story. Well, it’s a fascinating and sobering tale full of insight into life and the nature of… oops, wait, those were my notes for The Kite Runner. Rumped Stiltsken is… well, just read it, OK?

Colin Adams entertains us with this and many other humorously mathematical (mathematically humorous?) stories in his new book, Riot at the Calc Exam and Other Mathematically Bent Stories. Tips on how to avoid RERI (Repetitive Eye Roll Injury), advice from a mathematical ethicist, stories about everyone’s favorite Principal Investigator, Dirk Mangum, P. I., a transcript from the hit radio show Math Talk with Plug and Chug… the list goes on. Some are funnier than others, of course (by the end, the conceit of anthromorphizing/metaphorizing mathematical theorems and the process or proving them had gotten particularly old), but on balance my Funny-o-Meter was definitely pointing somwhere between “amusing” and “hilarious”. This book would make a great gift for that special person in your life who likes to read funny stories about math while they are in the bathroom, or for anyone who likes reading funny stories about math in general, or anyone who likes funny stories, or who likes math. This book would not make a good gift for grumpy people who hate math. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

Full disclosure: the AMS kindly sent me a free review copy of this book. Also, Colin Adams was actually one of my professors in college, which you might think would make me somewhat biased, which is probably true, but it also means that I happen to know that he really is quite funny, and also that he is the Fastest Draw(er of 3D surfaces with colored chalk) in the West(ern Massachusetts). Also also, this morning for breakfast I ate a bowl of shredded wheat cereal.

Logicomix: An Epic Search for Truth

Monday, November 2nd, 2009


I recently acquired a copy of Logicomix: An Epic Search for Truth, by Apostolos Doxiadis and Christos Papadimitriou, with art by Alecos Papadatos and Annie Di Donna. It defies categorization: is it a comic book? A biography? A book of philosophy? Of history? Of mathematics? Well, it’s all of these things, and manages to pull it off with grace and style.

Logicomix is a graphic novel focusing on the story of Bertrand Russell, the English mathematician and philosopher, and the quest at the beginning of the twentieth century to discover a logically rigorous foundation for mathematics. This quest had a surprising outcome: in one sense, it was a failure; in another sense, it led directly to the development of computers! If you want to know what I mean… you’ll have to read the book.

It’s beatifully and smartly illustrated, and tells a riveting story, interspersed with meta-narrative about the authors of Logicomix and their process of planning and writing it. If you read Logicomix expecting a comprehensive mathematical history of this time period in comic book form, you’ll be disappointed. It really is telling the stories of the people involved, with big mathematical ideas explained as necessary (although the mathematical explanations it does include are creative and clear). Fortunately, the people are rather fascinating! Like E.T. Bell’s Men of Mathematics, Logicomix certainly dispels the myth that mathematicians are dull. Logicomix would make a great addition to any library, but I particularly recommend it to middle and high school teachers for lending to students!